Crypto Transaction Opinions for DeFi, Staking, and Token Questions
Staking, liquid staking, wrapping, bridging, liquidity pools, airdrops, token grants, and token classification raise tax questions the IRS has not clearly addressed. A crypto transaction opinion applies the law to your specific transactions and states a conclusion at a defined confidence level, in writing, before you file.
It gives you and your return preparer a documented basis for the position. If the IRS later challenges it, a well-supported opinion may help show that you relied on professional advice and acted in good faith.
Crypto Questions We Analyze
Each opinion is built around your actual transactions, wallets, and protocols, not a general summary of the rules.
What the IRS Has Addressed, and What It Hasn't
The IRS has issued guidance on a handful of crypto questions. Most DeFi activity still falls into the gaps, which is where a written opinion is most useful. Broker reporting on Form 1099-DA, which began with 2025 transactions, makes consistent, documented positions more important.
| Topic | What the IRS has said | What remains open |
|---|---|---|
| Crypto as property | Notice 2014-21 treats virtual currency as property for federal tax purposes. | How the general rules apply to newer DeFi structures. |
| Hard forks and airdrops | Rev. Rul. 2019-24: income when you receive new units and have dominion and control over them. | Locked, vesting, and claimable tokens, and how to value them at receipt. |
| Staking rewards | Rev. Rul. 2023-14: rewards are income when a cash-method taxpayer gains dominion and control. | Liquid staking, restaking, and receipt tokens. |
| Wrapping and bridging | No direct guidance. | Whether moving to a wrapped or bridged token is a taxable disposition. |
| Liquidity pools | No direct guidance. | How deposits, LP tokens, and withdrawals are treated. |
Confidence Levels, Penalties, and Limits
An opinion states a conclusion at a defined confidence level and explains the reasoning. It does not change the underlying tax, and it does not bind the IRS. What it does is document that a qualified professional analyzed the position before you acted.
If the IRS challenges the position, that documentation may help support a reasonable cause and good faith defense to certain accuracy-related penalties, which are generally 20% of the underpayment and 40% in certain cases. The confidence level matters because different penalty and disclosure rules attach to each level.
Will
90%+ likely to prevailClear law. Common as a transaction closing condition.
Should
About 70% to 75%Most reorganization and structuring opinions.
More likely than not
Over 50%Required, along with disclosure and substantial authority, for the penalty defense on reportable transactions.
Substantial authority
About 35% to 40%Avoids the substantial understatement penalty without disclosure. The standard a preparer needs to sign an undisclosed position.
Reasonable basis
About 20% to 30%Avoids that penalty only if the position is disclosed on the return. Never enough for tax shelter items.
These percentages are practitioner conventions, not numbers set by law. "More likely than not," "substantial authority," and "reasonable basis" are standards used in the tax code and regulations; "will" and "should" are not.
When an opinion letter may not help. There are situations where an opinion letter cannot provide a penalty defense. For example, the penalty for a transaction that lacks economic substance (20%, or 40% if undisclosed) cannot be removed through reasonable cause, even if you obtained an opinion. An opinion also may not help if it relies on inaccurate facts or unreasonable assumptions, and reportable transactions are subject to stricter reliance rules.
Timing also matters. An opinion obtained after the IRS begins asking questions cannot establish that you relied on the opinion when you originally filed your return.
At Gordon Law, we discuss the confidence level your facts may support during the initial scoping process, before you commit to the full opinion.
From Scoping Call to Signed Letter
Most crypto transaction opinions take a few weeks once the records are in hand, longer when on-chain history has to be reconstructed first. Start before you file the return that reports the transactions.
- Scoping CallWe discuss the tax question, the amounts involved, and the confidence level your facts may support. This initial conversation also helps determine whether a formal opinion letter is the right approach for your situation. The scoping call is a paid consultation ($495).
- FactsYou'll provide transaction records, wallet and exchange histories, protocol documentation, and what you've reported so far. Our CPAs can help reconstruct on-chain transaction history when needed.
- AnalysisOur attorneys analyze the position under the Code, regulations, rulings, and case law, and identify the more conservative and more assertive positions available, along with the risks of each.
- Signed Opinion LetterYou'll have an opportunity to review a draft and confirm that the facts are accurate. Once finalized, you receive the signed opinion letter to keep with your tax records and share with your preparer or other permitted recipients.
Get an opinion before you file your return or close the transaction. The IRS user fee is based on Rev. Proc. 2026-1. Reduced fees apply to certain lower-income filers.
Who Handles Your Opinion Letter Matters
A tax opinion letter involves more than reviewing the tax rules. It requires a detailed understanding of the law, the facts of your situation, and how the two apply to the position being evaluated.
At Gordon Law, opinion letters are prepared and signed by the firm’s attorneys, with support from the firm’s CPAs on the financial details. You’ll know who is handling your matter and who is responsible for the legal analysis behind your opinion.
Questions About Crypto Transaction Opinions
Straight answers to some of the questions that come up most often. If you have questions about your specific situation, we can discuss those during a consultation.
Generally when the amount at stake is significant, when your preparer won’t sign the return without written support, or when the position will recur every year and you want it analyzed once. For a smaller position, a documented memo may be enough. We’ll tell you which during scoping.
There’s no way to guarantee that. The IRS does not approve opinions in advance, and an opinion does not bind the IRS or a court. If the IRS challenges the position, a well-supported opinion may help show reasonable cause and good faith, and it lays out the analysis behind your position.
A few weeks for most transactions once the records are in hand, longer when the on-chain history has to be reconstructed first.
Whatever the analysis supports. We discuss the level your facts may support during scoping, before you commit to the full opinion. If the position is unlikely to hold up, you should know that before paying for a letter.
Yes. Return preparation is handled by our tax team at Gordon Law. When a position needs to be reflected on a return, our attorneys and tax team coordinate directly.
Generally no. You keep it with your records and provide it if the IRS asks. Some positions must also be disclosed on the return itself, on Form 8275 or, for reportable transactions, Form 8886. The opinion will address whether yours does. Keep in mind that sharing the opinion with third parties, including the IRS, may waive attorney-client privilege.
Other Opinion Letters and Guides
Compare the other opinions we prepare, or read more about where the rules stand.